Don’t Forget the Title! 5 Common Mistakes to Avoid When Donating Your Vehicle
You’ve made the generous decision to donate a vehicle to a charity. You’ve picked a cause you believe in, and you’re ready to see that old car do some good. But before you hand over the keys and watch the tow truck pull away, there is one piece of paper that can make or break the entire experience: the vehicle title.
In the world of vehicle donations, the title is more than just a proof of ownership—it is a legal instrument that transfers liability and secures your right to a tax deduction. Unfortunately, many donors treat it as an afterthought, leading to IRS headaches or unexpected legal bills.
To ensure your donation is as seamless as possible, avoid these five common title-related mistakes.
1. Leaving the "Buyer" Section Blank
This is perhaps the most dangerous mistake a donor can make. It is tempting to leave the buyer’s name blank, thinking it makes things "easier" for the charity or the auction house. This is known as an "open title."
The Risk: If the title is lost or stolen before it is officially processed, anyone can write their name in and claim ownership. Furthermore, until a buyer is named, you are still the owner of record. If the car is involved in an accident or used in a crime after it leaves your driveway, you could be held legally liable.
The Fix: Always ask the charity exactly what name should be written in the buyer/assignee section. Most will ask you to write the name of the non-profit or their authorized processing agent.
2. Failing to Clear Liens Before Donating
If you still owe money on your car, or if you recently paid it off but never received the "Lien Release" from your bank, you cannot legally donate the vehicle. A charity cannot sell or use a car that has an active lien because they don't have clear title to it.
The Risk: The charity may pick up the car, only to call you weeks later saying they can't process it. This stalls your tax deduction and creates a logistical nightmare.
The Fix: If you’ve paid off your loan, ensure you have the Lien Release document from the lender. In many states, you must attach this document to the original title when you hand it over.
3. Making "Corrections" with White-Out or Cross-Outs
The title is an official government document. In almost every state, any sign of tampering—such as using white-out, crossing out a misspelled name, or writing over a number—will immediately void the title.
The Risk: A voided title means the charity cannot transfer ownership. You will be forced to apply for a duplicate title through the DMV, which costs money and can take weeks to arrive.
The Fix: Use a steady hand and blue or black ink. If you make a mistake, do not try to fix it. Stop immediately and contact the charity’s title department. They can often provide a "Statement of Facts" form that allows the DMV to accept the correction legally.
4. Not Checking for "And" vs. "Or" on Joint Titles
If the vehicle is registered to more than one person, pay very close attention to the conjunction between the names.
The "And" Rule: If the title says "John Doe AND Jane Doe," both parties must sign the title for the donation to be valid.
The "Or" Rule: If it says "John Doe OR Jane Doe," usually only one signature is required.
The Risk: If you only provide one signature when two are required, the tow driver may refuse the pickup, or the title will be rejected later in the process.
5. Forgetting to File the "Release of Liability"
Handing over the signed title is only half the battle. To officially "sever the tie," you must notify your state’s DMV that you no longer own the car.
The Risk: Even with a signed title, the DMV’s computer system may still show you as the owner until the new buyer registers it. This can lead to you receiving automated notices for unpaid registration, parking tickets, or even toll road violations.
The Fix: Immediately after the car is towed, go to your state DMV website and file a Notice of Transfer and Release of Liability (NRL). Most states allow you to do this online in under five minutes. Keep a printed copy of the confirmation for your records.
Summary Checklist for a Flawless Transfer
To keep your donation on track, use this quick checklist before the tow truck arrives:
| Task | Done? |
| Verified the charity is a qualified 501(c)(3) | ☐ |
| Confirmed the title is in your name and clear of liens | ☐ |
| Signed the title exactly as your name appears on the front | ☐ |
| Removed the license plates (if required by your state) | ☐ |
| Photographed both sides of the signed title for your records | ☐ |
| Filed the Release of Liability with the DMV | ☐ |
Your Generosity Deserves a Smooth Process
Donating a vehicle to a charity is a high-impact way to support the community, but the "paperwork" part is what protects you and ensures the charity gets the most value. By taking these few extra steps to handle the title correctly, you can focus on the good you’re doing rather than worrying about the fine print.
Turn Your Old Set of Wheels Into a Lifeline: The Ultimate Guide to Donating a Vehicle to Charity